If the Bough Breaks - Raising Awareness of the Medical Liability Insurance Crisis in Maryland
 
if the bough breaks  
if the bough breaks raising awareness of the medical liability crisis is maryland
background
documentary
your support
take action
  NEWS Revisions in Fees for Doctors Promised
  in the news
contact us
  By Andrew A. Green
From The Baltimore Sun
November 19, 2004

Gov. Robert L. Ehrlich Jr. told the leaders of the House and Senate yesterday that he will revise his plan to hold down medical malpractice insurance premiums, but the three are no closer to agreement on how to pay for it.

The governor said he saw "a path being blazed" for a special session before year's end in which the legislature would create a fund to avoid a 33 percent premium increase - scheduled to go into effect for most doctors in January - and enact limits on malpractice lawsuits to hold down premiums in the long term.

Some doctors have said they will have to retire, leave Maryland or stop performing high-risk procedures if the increase takes effect.

Ehrlich, Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller and House Speaker Michael E. Busch described their meeting, the first since last month, as intense and productive. But the three left with basic disagreements about what went on.

Ehrlich said he has a preferred revenue source for the fund, but he wouldn't identify it. After emerging from the meeting, Miller and Busch said that if Ehrlich has a funding source in mind other than the state's general fund, they don't know what it is.

Miller and Busch said the governor told them that a 2 percent tax on health maintenance organization premiums was "off the table." Ehrlich didn't go that far in his comments after the meeting but said the HMO tax is "not my preferred course."

The three didn't even agree on when they had decided to meet next.

The legislative leaders said they would talk again Wednesday, and Ehrlich saying the next meeting would be Dec. 1.

A Senate task force studying malpractice issues is scheduled to complete its recommendations Dec. 1.

The pace of discussions among the staffs of the governor and the legislative leaders has intensified in recent days, as have talks with the doctors, trial lawyers, hospitals and insurance companies that would be affected by a reform package.

Ehrlich said there is substantial agreement on provisions to improve patient safety. Miller, who has been reluctant to endorse the limits on lawsuits that Ehrlich has pushed for, known as tort reform, said the Senate will agree to some of the governor's proposals.

"Hopefully, we can get something done before January," Miller said.

The legislature will return in its regular session in January, but Ehrlich, Miller and Busch have said they want a solution before the first of the year so that the rate increase, which is to go into effect then, won't prompt doctors to leave the state or retire.

With petitions from a majority of both houses of the legislature, the General Assembly could call a special session without the governor's consent. Busch has collected the signatures of more than half of the delegates, but he said he would prefer a solution on which all sides agree.

"This is our top priority to solve this issue," Busch said. "We are ready to take action."